Find your Fire Island sanctuary in Fair Harbor, NY with Frontline Realty Group. This beloved Fire Island community is one of the barrier island's most popular destinations — known for its lively social scene, pristine ocean beach, and family-friendly atmosphere. Properties in Fair Harbor are in high demand as both summer homes and investment properties. With no cars allowed on Fire Island, Fair Harbor offers a truly unique lifestyle defined by boardwalks, ocean breezes, and community. Our agents specialize in Fire Island real estate — contact us today.
Fair Harbor Listings Summary
Fair Harbor - Town
vs. County Stats
Avg Price in Fair Harbor: $1,699,000
/ County Avg
$1,494,100
114%
Avg Taxes in Fair Harbor: $9,300
/ County Avg
$23,800
39%
Avg Sq. Ft. in Fair Harbor: 1,694
/ County
Avg 2,561
66%
Avg Price per/sqft in Fair Harbor:$1003
/ County Avg $583
172%
Avg Year Built in Fair Harbor: 1972
/ County Avg 1973
100%
Avg Days on Website in Fair Harbor: 139
/ County Avg 89
156%
Fair Harbor
Real Estate Market Health
New Listings
Reductions
Foreclosures
Short Sales